But the acting and world building is still magnificent, and it's still an ejoyable movie. Even when the Hobbit book was aimed at Tolkien's children, this movie goes too far in it's 'childishness'. Each time I see Sam saying 'I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you' I cry a bit. I give it 0,1 less cause I just enjoy FOTR more. Almost perfect introduction of the world and characters, focusing correctly on the adventurous nature of the first book. I'm still watching the Hartwell Cut, so I can't comment too much on it, but I'm surprised at how well made it is despite being made to be closer to PJ's the Hobbit instead of a book accurate fan edit.įOTR: 9,5/10. JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit - 7.5, literally just a slightly less good version of the M4 cut.

It cut out a bit too much for my liking, but it didn't end up feeling painfully rushed like I expected it to. M4 cut of the Hobbit - 8/10, turned that 5/10 Trilogy into an 8/10 movie. You just watch fights for 2 hours straight and then forget about it. I was bored to death with rings of power, but I've never hated more changes and additions than the ones in desolation of smaug.īattle of the Five armies - 5/10, it's pretty much a turn your brain off film for me. Unexpected Journey - 6/10, I was bloated already.ĭesolation of smaug - 4/10, smaug was cool but they added so much stuff I hated.

If you are discussing something new, such as the recent Hobbit movies, please use spoiler tags as follows: (/spoiler)Īnd remember NOT to put spoilers in your post titles! If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world! Legolas, Aragorn and Gimli Snoos created by Tom Sexton LoTR - Wikipedia Page Spoiler Tags - USE THEM! Tolkien Related Multi-Reddit to Rule them All Recommended Sites

The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorhthelm's Sonįor a full recommended Tolkien reading list, please CLICK HERE - written by ebneter Related Subreddits.

Lord Of The Rings (Including Appendices).

Don't Criticize Others For Their Opinionsĭetails of rules are HERE Tolkien Recommended Reading.

For all things Tolkien, The Lord Of The Rings, The Hobbit, Silmarillion, and more.

Download free hobbit barrel escape